Search This Blog/Links/The Web

Saturday, March 17, 2012


Multitasking: Boon or Bane? Chris Stefanski and Dennis McElroy 

Class 422,

Two viewpoints, two extremes, are embraced in the article Multitasking: Boon or Bane?  written by Stefanski and McElroy.  Both perspectives offer valid points, but they relinquish to talk about the importance of what can occur between the “boon” and the “bane”.  Stefanski (2012) states that with his enormous daily workload routine, “We are all expected to be constantly accessible and connected, so we have no choice but to multitask.”  At what cost? Would I jeopardizes my own equanimity to push it like he suggests?  I think I would try to find a happy medium a place where I find my wise mind leading the way.  Where I do agree with Stefanski is that he advocates that the only way to become better at multitasking is to practice.  This of course, would hone the skills needed to productively navigate through all the technological information that is so abundant and would  also foster my ability to efficiently jump between tasks.  Practice makes perfect.  Then there is McElroy’s (2012) angle which emphasizes focus on one task at a time and that, “there’s no way students can do it to their highest potential if their attention is elsewhere”.  He goes on to explain that humans are constantly taking in and processing information; though paradoxically this is why we get sidetracked and why we sometimes lack focus on a task in the first place.  McElroy (2012) argument resonates with me more so in that to complete a job I must be able to focus on that task and allocate other tasks to “…appropriate, lesser levels of awareness”.  
I think the ability to multitask and process information runs along a spectrum; a spectrum between the two thoughts proposed by these authors. Multitasking is not as black and white as the two suggest.  I believe the ability to work on multiple tasks is subjective to the individual.  It requiring great focus and can be beneficial if the final product is systematically accomplished.   Most importantly, I think being mindfully attentive that there is this spectrum between excessive multitasking and doing only one thing at a time is the awareness I need to successfully navigate between both.  With the constant inundation of new information within our shifting educational setting, I feel it is imperative to practice completing one task at a time, but still keeping the notion to confidently and attentively use critically thinking skills in order to conquer other tasks. The key for me is to not take multitasking to either extreme, as sited, and use keen mindfulness so tasks are met. 
Thank You For Your Time,

Thomas

Reading Blog Post #4 (Choice)
 
McElroy, D. and Stefanski, C. (2012).  Multitasking: Boon or Bane? Learning and Leading with Technology, 39(6), 6-7. Retrieved from http://www.iste.org/learn/publications/learning-and-leading/DigitalEditionMarch-April2012.aspx

2 comments:

422MarissaCarney said...

Hi Thomas!

I agree with your approach to multitasking. If nothing is being learned or accomplished because so much multitasking is taking place, in the end, all of the effort and time may be wasted. If a person maintains a single focus, so much else can be missed in the meantime. There are, however, certain tasks where less focus is needed and multitasking is most effective and still others where a single focus is needed. That is why I agree that people need to maintain an awareness in order to "successfully navigate between both." Practice is definitely necessary as most people are usually prone to one extreme or the other. As someone who likes to do one thing well instead of several things half-heartedly, I have found that a proper balance is always key and usually dependent upon the task at hand. Great insight and input!

Blessings,
Marissa Carney

Tyler A. Eytchison said...

Thomas,

First I would like to say how great it is that you picked an article that spoke to you. That's awesome. Second, I think your assessment is interesting since it is not necessarily the most common viewpoint towards the topic. Although I certainly agree with you that focusing on a single task allows for a more cohesive and complete body of work, most people would stress the importance of multitasking. One of the most common characteristics required for new job listings is the ability to multitask. I agree that a medium is definitely needed so that you do not wear yourself thin, and you are not compromising the quality of work. Thanks for your input!

Tyler A. Eytchison

Post a Comment